The Bullet: Mysteries
& Myths -
Don't just love but get to
know your bullet more
- by B. R. Gurunandan
Running-in a new Bullet:
"A properly run-in machine will
have just enough clearance between mating surfaces to permit an
unbroken oil-film under normal operating conditions"
After ages and ages of dreaming and lusting, you have finally taken
delivery of your new Bullet.
The manual warns you; the dealer warns you; your friends warn you:
Run it in correctly, they say, or else...
In face of this united chorus, you almost wilt. But not quite ! Bulleteers, as a rule, will not be stubborn, but they won't be pushed
into anything willy-nilly, either !
Or else, what ? you ask, innocently but firmly. The dealer looks
incredulous. But you won't back out ! And he is forced to play his
trump-card on the back foot : The warranty does not cover misuse. And no,
he can't qualify "misuse". It is just about any thing you admit to
having done when you go to report a problem during warranty period.
Your friends don't know either ! They were simply passing on what they
had heard said, just to be helpful (?) to a friend.
Impasse ?
Hardly ! For a Bullet-eer it is just a beginning of a fascinating voyage
of discovery.
What is this running-in; what is it for; how strict are the guidelines
to be followed; indeed, what ARE the guidelines ?!!
Really, in this day & age, "don't exeed 50Km/ h for first 3000Km;
change oil at 500" hardly classifies as a technical guideline ! More of
a "fatwa": Incomplete, illogical, and arbitrary.
This time we re-wind into History ! The history of
manufacturing-technology. To us techies swearing by CAD, CAM & CNC
it comes as a jolt to realise that not soooo long ago, the
mass-production of components was only a small part of the story. To
make a reliable machine, they had to be assembled by highly skilled
craftsmen to get the required slackness/ tightness of fit !! In short,
the parts could not be economically produced to required tolerances.
The success of several legendary marques of the motoring world is
attributed to the skill of these artisans: Some manufacturers went to
the extent of engraving the name of the assembler on each engine, just
like a painting or work of art!
Forward now, not to Bullets, but to Guns ! Very recently, I came across
an interesting article about a prosperous gunsmith firm specialising in
rebuilding NEW handguns for better precision and reliability. This they
do by plating/ lapping until all the clearances are exactly enough and
no more. Their labour-charges were USD 500 for a gun costing USD 400. And
the gun was manufactured by a reputed company whose logo is a frisky
horse.
Whatever the technology, the mechanism can always be
improved by manual fitting. But the cost more than
doubles with hardly a dozen parts to be fitted
Finally, we come back to familiar terrain: Who has not freed a seized
door-hinge by liberal application of penetrating-oil and cycling
open/ shut with gradually increasing amplitude. If the entire operation
was attempted in a single try, something would have bent/ broken!
Hmmmm. So here is an alternative ! Neither you have to manufacture to
space-shuttle tolerances nor you have to hand-fit the parts. Just aim
for interference-fit where running-fit was needed, and it will wear
itself to a lovely running-fit if progressively run-in like the hinge !
So that was the run-up to running-in.
Which you have done by "the book":
3000Kms never exceeding 50Kmph, Oil-change on the dot at
authorised-dealer's, and all.
Feeling smug ?
OK, ride out to the nearest National Highway one sunday morning (no
traffic) and open 'er up ! Ten minutes at 120Kmph, and it is even-money
that you have a seized engine and misc damage in forks & gearbox.
Oh, really ?!!! But how ?
And why didn't anyone ever mention it ?
Well, I just did, and the reason is not difficult to understand !
First we consider the
engine construction:
Piston - Al Alloy; Rings - White Iron; Cylinder - Grey Iron;
Gudgeon, Crank Pins - Steel; Connecting Rod - Al Alloy; Floating Bush
....OK, OK, the point is that there are many different materials, which
have different co-efficients of thermal expansion. It stands to reason
that the clearance between the components will change as temperature
changes. The plot FURTHER thickens, if you believe me (Please do; I am
pretty good at Metallurgy) when I say that these materials are
non-homogenous ! I'm serious !! For example, Grey Cast Iron is particles
of graphite embedded in iron. The size & distribution of the
graphite is influenced by so many factors, you really don't want me to
list them here ! You'll just take my word for it when I say that in case
of a mass production piece, nobody can predict it's EXACT dimension at
a given temperature. Nobody but an insurance salesman :-)
Now consider engine temperature:
It depends mainly on the balance between (a) the heat from the burnt
fuel, from friction and (b) the heat removed by the exhaust gases, by
air, by oil. Rises with rising engine RPM.
Back to running-in.
You have run-in your bike at 50Kmph. Which means, at the corresponding
temperature T(50), the clearances are ideal. The next step is to make
them likewise at T(60) where
T(60) = T(50) + DeltaT
and NOT at T(120) where
T(120) = T(50) + n DeltaT where n>>1 , right ? :-)
Don't like "mathematical" formulae ? , eh ? :-)
OK, try this:
Recall (or visit) a machine shop. Observe how the machinist removes
material from the workpiece to bring it down to the required dimension.
He traverses the length repeatedly, advancing the tool SLIGHTLY each
time, removing a LITTLE material each time, obtaining a pretty decent
finish too. Try removing the whole lot in one pass, and you'll neither
get accuracy nor a good finish! If you were very lucky. If not,
screeeeeeeEEEE-KRAK-crrrruNCHH. Overheat, smoke, tool breakage,
system-seizure.
See any connection ? :-)
In other words, even if you have already "run-in" the engine at 50Kmph,
you should progressively expose it to higher speeds and gradually form
the clearances for best finish and fit. If you directly go to 120Kmph,
the clearances might suddenly close-up, scrubbing off the oil-film and
creating a rough unstable finish. If you are unluckier, crrrrrruNCHHH!
Now, should you take your chances on that, or should you take Nandan's
advise ?
Point One:
Even if your bike has been used for YEARS in the city, say at 70Kmph
max, DON'T try holding 120Kmph steady on the first interstate trip!
Run-in the engine to 120Kmph first.
Point Two:
A suggested running-in method. Don't exceed 50Kmph for the first
1000Km. (OK, 3000 if you feel better that way) Then with engine warmed
at 50Kmph, go to 60 and hold it for not more than half a minute. Do not
repeat for at least 10 minutes (You can guess why, right ?) Repeat this
process atleast 5 times before proceeding to next step, which is the
same but holding time is one minute. Then repeat for 2min, 5min, 10min.
This may have taken several days or weeks! Repeat this for 75, 95 and
then 120 Kmph. NOW you can say your bike is run-in.
Point Three:
OK, you didn't take Nandan seriously, and chased a car on the NH
without looking at speedo nor watch. Your engine suddenly goes
uh-uh-uh-uh-uh and you grab the clutch and coast to a standstill
praying it is a case of fuel-starvation, nothing worse. But the
kickstarter is like the footrest ! Immovable. And the oil-filler is
smoking like a chimney. Curses ! Why didn't anybody warn you ! Worse,
what nex ! Relax. If it is any consolation, you are not the first
person to have this happen to. Nor the last. Not until Nandan writes
the Bullet-manual !!! Relax, because if you have grabbed the clutch in
time, the engine will free itself in about 5 to 15 minutes, and the oil
would have stopped smoking. First, open the sump-plug ( front, not the
rear one, that is the oil-tank plug ), and let the oil drain. Gently
kick the engine over, with decompressor pulled, listening for any
unhealthy noises, feeling for resistances. To be on the safe side wait
half an hour, which you can utilise getting some engine oil if
possible. Now start the engine without putting back the plug. Yes, I
know that the scavenge-pump and rockers are running "dry", but that is
the lesser of the evils. Oil will start dripping from the sump-plug
hole. ( Collect it and examine for metal-particles...Always nice to analyse the stable after the horse has run away ! ) Now & then, rev
the engine for better oil-distribution and cleanup. After about five
minutes, or after you feel about 250 ml of oil has been lost -in case
you could not get more oil- screw in the sump plug and proceed to your
destination. Change oil as soon as possible. Hear a rat-tat-tat-tat
from the engine nowadays ? That is because the piston has been "grated"
on the dry cylinder wall till it has lost some diameter, and rock/play
against the cyl wall is now possible. Don't worry. It is not an
emergency situation, it can be ridden safely for months ( Ask me how I
know ! ) before changing the piston.
By B. R. Gurunandan
Click
here to email your queries to Nandan.